the policy dispute
By Michael Doyle / Bee Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON — Sen. Edward Kennedy needs Marna Vasquez, and vice versa.
Vasquez is a packinghouse worker from Porterville. Kennedy is a rich and famous Democratic senator from Massachusetts.
Nonetheless, the 37-year-old former illegal immigrant and the 75-year-old lawmaker briefly shared a Capitol Hill stage this week to push for sweeping immigration revisions.
Vasquez needs Kennedy’s bill to help her friends and neighbors. He needs her voice to persuade congressional fence-sitters.
"I have a lot of faith that we’re going to win," Vasquez said. "That’s how we feel."
But there are strong feelings on all sides of the immigration debate, which resumes Tuesday in the Senate. The long-term prospects remain unclear. Vasquez’s walk-on role helps raise the curtain, showcases Capitol Hill tactics and reveals a human face behind the policy dispute.
Spanning 762 pages, the complicated measure would offer legal status to illegal immigrants in the United States, now estimated to number some 12 million.
It also would add border protections and establish new guest-worker programs.
Some two dozen amendments await what supporters call "the grand bargain."
Some are innocuous, such as a proposal to fund "refugee scholars." Some are intended to sabotage the bill, such as a proposal to prohibit the newly legal immigrants from obtaining permanent legal U.S. residency.
The immigration fight spans many fronts.
Some are formal set pieces, such as the Senate debate itself. Some have the potential to be far more influential, such as private deal-making among senators.
Some fill the airwaves, such as the ads running in Kentucky urging Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell to oppose the bill.
Then there is the multifaceted bit of theater known as the news conference.
Late Thursday morning, Vasquez donned a red United Farm Workers T-shirt to stand with Kennedy, UFW President Arturo Rodriguez and Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein. Before a dozen camera crews, speakers cheered on an agricultural guest-worker program that is included in the comprehensive immigration bill.
Dubbed AgJobs, the package would grant U.S. residency to 1.5 million illegal immigrants with farm experience.
"Real fruit requires real people," Rodriguez said, summing up the case for securing a legal labor supply.
Feinstein and Kennedy have convened numerous news conferences in the past two years to champion immigration overhaul.
Behind the prepared remarks and arid PowerPoint displays at Thursday’s news conference, real people live and breathe. Enter Marna Vasquez.
"Now," Vasquez said, "I understand what is important; to work together, to see that our dreams come true."
She and a Porterville friend, Angebala Zabala, left Los Angeles by train a week ago.
In time, they were joined by about 100 other farmworkers and immigrants on the so-called Dreams Across America Tour.
Supported by churches and unions, the trip delivered immigrants to Washington for nearly a week’s worth of public and private lobbying.
In 1986, Kennedy helped write the Immigration Reform and Control Act, which offered amnesty to more than 2.7 million illegal immigrants. That same year, Vasquez and her mother entered the United States illegally in a harrowing journey.
"We walked for 24 hours," Vasquez said in an interview. "The temperature was 120 degrees. One of the guides — the coyote — was screaming at us, saying, ‘You have to go, you have to run.’ We didn’t have water. We didn’t have food."
Amnesty will be much discussed during the Senate debate that resumes Tuesday, but Vasquez won’t have much time to watch it on C-SPAN. Now a naturalized U.S. citizen, she’ll be back at the packinghouse, working extra hard, she said, to send money to her brothers back in Mexico.
The reporter can be reached at mdoyle@mcclatchydc.com or(202)383-0006.